The first rule of Burger Club: Burgers are made of beef. The team of sandwich eating professionals that brought you Winnipeg’s Best Club House, Reuben and Gyro, now embark on a life long quest to find Winnipeg’s best burgers. Yes, burgers – we’re going to rate the best Bacon, Cheese, Chili, Fatboy, Greek and Mushroom burgers. I know what you’re thinking – there are already several lists for Winnipeg’s Best Burger – but we bring the science – we have spreadsheets!
The Cibo Waterfront Café did it all right. They dished out top notch burgers and service in a wonderful setting to 21 hungry Burger Clubbers for Burger Week.
Cibo is located in the old James Street pumping station at 339 Waterfront Dr hidden behind the colourful Mere hotel in the revitalized Exchange District waterfront. The interior is a large, bricked space brightly lit from the tall windows. From the pedestrian walk hanging off the outside of the building you have a great view of the Red River, Alexander Docks and The Forks skyline. “Lovely use of an existing building” wrote Bess.
The Burger Week organizers look for restaurateurs with a sense of humour who can rise to the challenge of creating a special burger. Cibo’s entry, the “Rob Ford” with “Smoked Crack(ed) Black Pepper Beer Bun, Hand Cut Bacon, 2 x 4 oz. Smash Patties, Smoked Cabbage Coleslaw, House Pickles and Charred Onion Aioli” fit the bill perfectly. Burger Club was lucky enough to be on "The Main Ingredient with Chef Rob" on CJOB and you can hear Russell Loewen’s interview with Rob Thomas and Burger Week cofounder Na'eem Adam here.
I had originally booked us for 12 people and there was a barely discernible pause over the phone from Dean, the manager, when I upped it to 20. When we arrived a fellow was hustling near the entrance and I asked if he was Dean and he replied "I wish! I'm just a lowly server." That was Liam, our server, and he was great – he was a pistol and a quick and attentive server. They were staffed up in the back and front of the house and it felt like everyone working at Cibo was there to make us happy. Geoff wrote “I felt like a VIP sitting at the giant table with 20 people in the middle of the open air room.” It’s a popular restaurant and the patio, bar and dining room were all busy.
Cibo has a great bar selection and we sampled the drinks while they cooked up our burgers. Granville Island Hefeweizen was the popular on-tap choice. Stan raved “They have a great Caesar drink! A very unique smoky rimmer.” The barista created a message of love in Dani’s latte.
When Cibo set down the first wave of burgers, out came the cameras as we all did our social networking due diligence. I saw four burger pictures in a row appear on Instagram and then a fifth from the kitchen with a picture of the dining room. Our group of 21 are hiding behind the bartender’s shaker.
The Rob Ford burger was impressive. Geoff wrote “The tower that arrived was an imposing sight, but once the two patties were compressed down into the buns it was manageable without resorting to cutting it in half.” It was a very well designed and balanced burger from the fissured smashed patties to the lightly tanned bun. April whooped “The bun was fabulous, the meat well seasoned, the bacon was thick and the perfect texture; this is my new favourite burger.”
Karen described it well: “Fresh bun! Was the first thing that hit my nose. The burger's ragged edges gave away the handmade origin of this burger. Good bite factor as the burger is firm, juicy and nicely seasoned. I love the bacon, only wish it had been across the whole burger not huddled on one side. The pickles and sauces married well for an excellent overall flavour.” Bess added “The flavours of the burger and condiments were complex; a surprise with every bite.” Jeff wrote the “Bun:burger ratio was excellent to the last bite, and the bun held together admirably. This burger should be added to the regular menu - I'd definitely come back for it!”
Sandy had the regular menu single burger and said “There was so much I enjoyed about this burger - from the little onions within the patty to the slightly charred edges. The onion topping had a real vinegar like zing that I loved. The bun was fresh but struggled to contain the massive 8 oz patty. The bun was also very "greasy" and I found myself wiping my fingers after every bite. I'll be back!” Jacques also had the standard “Very tasty, moist and flavorful throughout, a hint of sweetness from the bun made for a divine experience.”
Most people loved their burger, but as always with a group of people with varying tastes, it didn't tickle the fancy of everyone. Burger Club brings you not just one opinion, but in this case, 21! The Rob Ford burger made special for burger week, averaged with the regular menu offering that 5/21 people had, placed Cibo at an impressive fifth place on Burger Club's ranking list. Several people wrote they thought the Rob Ford should stay on as a regular menu item. I think they want to know they can come back for another one. I can always tell when Burger Clubbers had a good time by how much they wrote in their review, and this week everyone had a lot to say about their meal and scrawled over a 1,000 words on their tiny slips of paper.
The shoestring fries received conflicted reviews. They tasted great and there were lots of them, but they were short and too crispy to fork. You couldn't pinch enough in your fingers to stuff in your mouth at once to make it worthwhile. Stan commented “The fries were kind of a waste of time.” Cary said they were "Like trying to eat a deep fried spider." The brothy smoked vegetable soup didn't excite. The side salads made people happy.
Burgers R Us forges gourmet burgers on Broadway. The flaming red truck offers an impressive nine beefy works of art on a bun, and Burger Club tried most of them. The day started out with a little rain, but the clouds parted so we could enjoy our burgers under the sun.
The truck wasn't always about burgers though. Sabrina and Blair McKibbon also own Healthy Eats and started a second rolling kitchen serving Portuguese food that my coworkers and I affectionately called the “Pork Chop Truck”. The meals were elaborate and sumptuous, but they realized quickly it wasn't going to work as a truck. A new flaming appliqué and menu and voila – homemade burgers for the Broadway crowd cooked up fresh by Blair’s brother Phil.
If you're shopping menus on Broadway, don’t be deterred by the $10 price tag at Burgers R Us. The beefy burgers are made fresh, flame broiled and easily twice the size of other truck patties. Everything on the menu comes with a side of onion rings. I assume the brothers farm onions in their spare time. I really enjoy a fresh onion ring, and these were piping hot and crispy delicious. If you don’t want the rings, they’ll take $2 off the price of your lone burger.
It can be a challenge to serve the lunch rush quickly, and a big thick patty takes time to cook. Burgers R Us flame broils the patties, places them in a steam box, then puts them back on the grill so you get your burger hot. When eleven of us showed up at once - as well as plenty of sidewalk surfers – Burgers R Us were handing out stacks as quick as they could assemble them.
The sandwiches were passed out the trailer window wrapped in foil-paper to those whose number matched the call. The onion rings accompanied in paper trays like little super-hero sidekicks. The “sitting wall” was still wet from the rain so we dined along a nearby fence which made a great burger bar.
A couple of us had the Avocado Burger and were treated to two slices of bright green alligator pear. The bun was a soft, sesame Kaiser and the leaf lettuce and tomato were bright and fresh. The patty was big and beefy, lightly charred from the flames and held together well. It was a filling burger that balanced well with the other flavours.
A few people had the Mushroom Swiss Burger. April wrote “The burger came with gravy and was pretty tasty. Even though I am not a fan of onion rings, these ones were really crispy and while I had planned on just trying one, I ate most of them. Well done! If this burger was served in a restaurant with comfortable seating, I think it would rate much higher as a whole. Too bad they don't serve milkshakes - It would have been the perfect complement to the burger!” Mireille added “The burger was piping hot and I could taste the char goodness. It was a very nice size as well. I enjoyed the gravy which had a nice mushroom flavour.”
Mark had the Chili Cheese Burger: “All meat extravaganza; no veggies - love it! Excellent charred burger. Real chili with a sweet flavour.” Burgers R Us make their own chili and pulled pork. Stephanie said the Pizza Burger was “Fun and tasty” but the photo of the burger on the TV menu was much less messy than hers with its foundation of homemade pizza sauce running down the bun.
Nelson had the Pulled Pork Burger and jotted “Lots of pulled pork, which was good but it overwhelmed everything else.” Russ had the Bacon Cheese Burger and wrote “A little bit of flame cooked love. The bacon was thick and smoky. It was curly though, so it made things fall apart. Great ingredients and a homemade patty.” Brian opted for the Bacon Ranch Burger and observed “The bun was fresh and sized right. The patty was seasoned nicely, topped with fresh lettuce and tomatoes, crisp bacon, and a flavorful ranch sauce. Overall this was a well-executed burger.”
Burgers R Us is usually the last food truck on Broadway. Phil and Blair told me how the parking patrol would start to get nervous around 2:30 pm. I asked how I could contact them and was handed a water bottle which confused me until I looked more closely at the flaming label – Twitter, e-mail address and a phone number for their sister trailer, Healthy Eats, that they can always be found with. Now that’s a handy business card on a hot day.
The white and red Mikky’s truck is a veritable institution on Broadway. Twenty-two years ago it belonged to Mikky, somewhere along the way it became Daryl’s, and for the last fifteen years it’s been owned by Don. Originally operating a hot dog cart, Don traded his umbrella for the metal roof of Mikky’s when the opportunity arose.
Don seems to have found the formula for success in the very competitive food truck market. An inexpensive and tasty burger, served quickly, draws lines of people to the Mikky’s order window on sunny lunch hours. Mikky’s feeds the parking meter in front of the WCB and sets itself apart from other trucks by laying out a line of welcome mats on the low granite wall for diners to settle their office attire wrapped derrieres onto. The nice lady taking orders was all smiles and Don came out to tell stories when there was a break in the lunch rush.
The deluxe cheeseburger is only $5, tax included. For $8 you can have fries and a drink with that. The deluxe burger comes standard with lettuce, tomato, fried onions and pickles. There are a couple of condiment stations hanging off the truck and a row of self serve drink coolers on the sidewalk. The mayo is wisely kept inside so it’s not sitting out in the sun. If you have just a burger, it comes nestled in a little wax paper pocket that’s perfect for one handing the burger while containing any fallout. The combo is served in a little cardboard tray that’s quite convenient if you’re sitting and using your lap as a table.
The first thing you notice when you sink your teeth into a Mikky’s burger is the big delicious City Bread bun. There’s plenty of fresh chopped lettuce - if you’re going to have any fallout, it’s going to be the lettuce. The groceries are rounded out with diced ripe tomato and fried onions – a favorite of mine and something you pay extra for at a lot of burger joints.
The thin beef patty gets lost in the bun and groceries. The flavour of this burger is in the bread and toppings. The beef is an inexpensive “store” patty that cooks fast and keeps the price down. I've had the single and decided to ask for a double burger today. That brought the burger-to-bun ratio to where it should be, but my double-meat tilted the flavour balance.
This was our most reviewed burger with twenty-one Burger Clubbers contemplating the sandwich. Mirreille commented “Would have preferred the patty to be bigger to fit the big bun. Enjoyed the grilled bun.” Cary referenced The Whole Nine Yards when he wrote “True Canadian means lots of mayo (Bruce Willis would hate it). Bun was too big, but good and fresh.” Stephanie, our local expert on street food exclaimed “Beautiful day for a food truck! Great deal for the combo. More than enough for me.”
Sandy raised the question of how to rate a burger: “This is my first food truck rating - not sure if I should be a little more generous on the presentation and comfort factors. Great fun!” Eric chimed in “Eating outside always trumps inside. Good for truck burger.” Stan summarized “Service was very quick. Value was excellent. Burger was pretty good, no complaints. The weather was perfect. The company was awesome.”
Victor thought it was a great deal: “If I could give a 6 for price I would. This was probably the most economically fair burger I've had this summer. The patty was kind of small, but the fries were awesome!”
Don suggested we try the European next time so I guess he’s still a hot dog guy at heart.
This week our mission of burgering under the sun led us to the Whistle Pig Drive-Inn (WPD) at 102 Victoria Ave E. Unicity tried and failed to assimilate Downtown Transcona, and as we passed under the arch, we knew we were leaving Winnipeg and journeying to some faraway land.
The WPD is a bonafide burger shack with a long history in the far east of Winnipeg. It’s had multiple owners and when asked, our window server said she didn't know where the name “Whistle Pig” came from. With a little research I learned it refers to a Groundhog. “Outside their burrow, individuals are alert when not actively feeding. It is common to see one or more nearly-motionless, standing erect on their hind feet watching for danger. When alarmed, they use a high-pitched whistle to warn the rest of the colony.” This seems like a sound survival technique and Burger Club will designate a Whistle Pig from now on while we loll in our meat comas.
The WPD offers a wide selection of burgers with all the standards plus a few that needed explaining:
The basic burgers come with mustard, ketchup and relish with cheese\bacon options.
The Chili Burger has chili sauce on it.
The Whistle Burger has chili, cheese, double bacon and onions (no lettuce or tomato).
The Banquet Burger has lettuce, tomato, cheese and bacon.
The Fatboy is a banquet minus the bacon.
The Chili Box Burger is a chili burger buried in chili.
The WPD suggested we pre-order to save time and that worked out well. When we arrived our burgers were ready and waiting, wrapped in foil-paper and delivered in splendid brown paper bags. Dani commented it was a “Beautiful, sunny day in Transcona. A great day for a window service burger.” There were lots of picnic tables with umbrellas for us to dine at. The patio’s overlooked by the Beatles and a mural of past icons that challenged our memories.
A few of us opted for the Whistle Burger which turned out to be a beef patty wrapped in chili wrapped in a bun. The chili was pleasant and there was lots of it. The beef patty provided some texture in the sandwich; otherwise it was uninteresting. I couldn't discern the cheese or bacon flavours. The chopped white onion added some depth to the burger foundation. The bun was very dry and flaky. Bill commented “More chili on burger than burger.” Mike wrote “This burger was all about chili. All other flavour was lost.” Victor agreed “Whistle Burger needed something other than chili to make it more memorable.”
The Banquet Burger was also a popular choice. April wrote “Burger was a little messy, lots of mayo and even though the patty itself was large, the bun overpowered the burger. If you skip the chili, you miss where the flavour's at.” Stephanie exclaimed “Banquet Burger reminded me of a Big Mac because of the overloaded Mayo.” Brian contemplated the characteristics with “The burger was good overall. It was tasty but fell apart making eating messy; the bun stayed together. The sauce added flavor without too much grease, the bacon was crisp and fresh, but the cheese, lettuce and other toppings were almost invisible.”
Karen reviewed the Fatboy “It had a soft Kaiser roll with tons of saucy lettuce and big tomato. The burger is chewy-thin and really dark coloured. I think it's most likely a bought burger. A filling burger for someone with a modest appetite.”
Finally, a couple of burgerettes had the bacon burger. “The patty looked like a frozen burger patty and kind of tasted like one as well but the bacon was nice and crispy” said Mireille. Dani wrote “Patty looks like it was preformed and frozen. It tastes okay, but no noticeable spicing. This was just a run-of-the-mill burger.”
Opinions varied on the fries and I suspect they tasted best when they were hot. Mike thought “the fries were great!” Brian wrote “Fries where below average.”
A wonderful feature of the WPD is that it shares the parking lot with a DQ and as everyone knows, burgers should always be followed up with ice-cream. A few folks opted for a strawberry cheesecake flavoured mini-Blizzard. All’s well, that ends well!